18 Things We Owned as Kids That We’d Pay Big Bucks to Have Again

Truths About Why Gen Z May Never Truly Own Anything

Ah, the nostalgia! Childhood was a simpler time, filled with treasures we didn’t realize were priceless until we grew up. Some of these beloved items are now highly sought-after collectibles, from toys that lit up our imaginations to gadgets that defined an era.

Get ready to walk down memory lane as we count down 18 things we all had as kids but would willingly shell out big bucks to own again.

Tamagotchis

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Chester/Wikimedia Commons

Do you remember obsessively feeding and cleaning a little digitized creature hanging from a key chain? Your mother probably yelled at you for carrying it during dinner, but Tamagotchis were life. These ’90s icons are making a comeback—actually. Original Tamagotchis can now be found on eBay for prices close to $300, while collectors are sneaking up on rare specimens.

Experts say the fascination with Tamagotchis fueled our early relationship with technology- and maybe even our love for virtual pets.

Polly Pocket

18 Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: lilolimao/Flickr

Polly Pockets were small toys with big dreams. Massively cute and miniature worlds in a compact case, they kept kids entertained for hours in the ’90s. In mint condition, a 1995 Polly Pocket Magical Mansion can now fetch $1,000+! Toy expert Matt Howes notes, “Polly Pocket turned the concept of toys on its head with its portable design and imaginative world-building.”

Easy-Bake Oven

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Erica Briggs/Flickr

That was indeed a Le Creuset; nothing could beat the feeling of baking a batch of mini cakes in light under a light bulb. The Easy Bake Oven was the ultimate gift for kids who aspired to become chefs.

A collector’s dream, original vintage models go for over $500 on online marketplaces, and to add to our nostalgia, Hasbro has also recently rolled out a modern version.

Beanie Babies

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Dominique Godbout/Flickr

That’s right! If your Ty Beanie Baby collection would pay for your college tuition, raise your hand! While most of us grossly overestimated their long-term worth, some rare models, such as the Princess Diana bear or Peanut the Elephant, still sell for thousands today.

An economist, Melissa Dalton, has called the whole Beanie Baby craze ‘a unique study in speculative markets fueled by childhood nostalgia.’

Game Boy Color

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Luiz Paulo Borges/Flickr

If you’re gripping your Game Boy Color anywhere and everywhere, you know what bliss is. Pokémon, anyone? These consoles are super nostalgic and valuable—pristine condition models go for $1,500 and up. Retro gaming analysts have conjectured that the current gamer market has driven up the value of vintage pieces as “reminders of simpler times.”

Snap Bracelets

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Weggart/Flickr

Before fidget spinners were fidget spinners, there were snap bracelets. These cheery accessories were the loudest yet worst representations of ’90s fashion. They weren’t pretty advanced, but who wouldn’t like to see snap bracelets redeployed in jewelry?

Depending on their condition, vintage styles have been sold on resale sites for around $20-200.

Lite-Brite

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Crystal/Flickr

There is something magical about creating glowing art with these little plastic pegs. Lite-Brite put thousands of twinkly lights into childhood bedrooms, and did we mention that it’s still around as a retro throwback? Sealed models from the ’80s and ’90s can now sell for over $250 to collectors hoping to plug into the past.

Cabbage Patch Kids

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image credits: Jeanne/Flickr

A slightly creepy yet unbearably cute Cabbage Patch Kid was generally a fundamental requirement for childhood. Each doll came primarily with an adoption certificate, making kids feel like legit parents. If you have one of the original first-edition dolls, you may be sitting on $1,000-$3,000.

Blockbuster Membership Card

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Tim Putala/Flickr

Okay, it’s not exactly an item to be held today, but nothing screams ’90s kid’ louder than a Blockbuster Membership Card. It was the ticket to weekend movie binges and heavy traffic down the aisles looking for the top release. The last Blockbuster surviving is closed down in Bend, Oregon, and is now a pilgrimage site for nostalgia.

Pogs

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: jerome_alfaro/Flickr

One could not carry out with anything more than a handful of Pogs and a bomb slammer. It was almost poker for kids. The ’90s witnessed an explosive rise of Pogs; elsewhere, the ease of play and collection had all the allure for kids. The Pogs started as a Hawaii game with milk caps and then metamorphosed into a craze worldwide.

Schools became battlegrounds where children would contest for coveted slammers with increasing creativity. Nowadays, some limited editions fetch more than $1,000 at auction.

Stretch Armstrong

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: D J/Flickr

Are there any fonder memories than seeing this blonde muscleman stretched till his arms were twice the length of one’s own? Original Stretch Armstrong toys from the 1970s and ’80s are considered collector’s items; some models fetch $4,000 if they remain in their original packaging.  

My Little Pony

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Hina Ichigo/Flickr

The colorful world of My Little Pony was not just fun-it was a full-fledged movement. The loveable ponies came with masterfully styled manes and tails, each with different symbols or “cutie marks” that made the girls’ creativity and imaginations soar. Limited-edition ponies, like the elusive “Rapunzel” or international exclusives from Europe, are especially coveted by collectors and sometimes command prices over $2,000 at auction.

With the My Little Pony fandom seeing a renaissance recently, pastel companions are considered even more desirable and have become collectible treasures as nostalgia sets in.  

Moon Shoes

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Tom/Flickr

Why walk when you could bounce? Moon Shoes may have been the worst safety hazard ever, but they were fun. Marketed initially during the 1990s, Moon Shoes were described as “mini trampolines for your feet” that gave children the thrill of anti-gravity. With the strong plastic platforms and heavy-duty rubber bands, kids could bounce around wearing the Moon Shoes and feel like they were defying gravity.

However, despite their clever design, the Moon Shoes took some skill to operate without falling; they invariably became partners in thrill and risk. With every nostalgic wave, the price of keeping their magic alive goes up, and there is no denying that these ’90s kids will still cherish Moon Shoes, with the vintage pairs popping up on the nostalgia market for over $200.  

Furbies

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Teh Bk/Flickr

Love them or hate them, Furbies were all the rage. They had the futuristic abilities to “learn” words. It was alive in some half-charitable way to most people, with blinking eyes and ears that wiggled as they uttered short phrases in “Furbish,” a language of their own.

Over the years, there were numerous iterations inspired by the Furbies. Still, it is the original line of Furbies stretching from 1998 to 2000 that offers treasure to collectors today, minimal editions like the Kid Cuisine or the Millennium Furby. Mint-condition Furbies from the initial release have been known to go for as high as $900 in resale markets.  

Fisher

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Naama A/Flickr

The Fisher-Price Record Player is connected to an early love for vinyl. These fat record players cut cool kids’ sounds on toy records. The original ones sold in the ’70s and ’80s? Now, its Three hundred to four hundred bucks, online, in varying conditions. Dust off the Fisher-Price Record Player if you are lucky enough to find one stashed away!

Lisa Frank Merchandise

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Hello Kat/Flickr

If Lisa Frank’s decor didn’t find its way into your room or school supplies, were you a ’90s kid? Lisa Frank’s items are back in style. Collectors are especially interested in trapper keepers, sticker sheets, and stationery sets featuring her signature designs. Rare and limited-edition items are where the big bucks are—think of rainbow unicorn binders or “Purrscilla” cat designs.

Some mint-condition items sell for upwards of $2000 in online auctions. Common finds, like enamel pins or pencil cases, can go for $50 to $100, depending on demand. The nostalgic charm of Lisa Frank continues to appeal to fans all around the world, making it a profitable waterway for collectors willing to devote their time and money.   

Hit Clips

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Taylor Evans/Flickr

Walking around with a Hit Clips music player meant carrying 30 seconds of Britney or NSYNC with you, right? It’s not precisely pocket-friendly today, but these are selling. Collectors are always on the lookout for rare-to-find or limited-issue Hit Clips. Some of the most sought-after tracks include those from Britney Spears, Backstreet Boys, and *NSYNC.

A pristine working player with several clips will easily fetch $200 and up, especially if the clips are in their original packaging. Nostalgic appeal ensures these tiny music wonders are always in demand among 2000s lovers.  

Converse All-Stars Limited Editions

Things We Owned As Kids That We'd Pay Big Bucks To Have Again
Image Credit: Converse/Flickr

They were cool anytime, but limited-edition Converse All-Stars of yesteryear are the levels of extraordinary people are willing to cough up to relive. For example, pairs from the Comme des Garçons PLAY collab, Grateful Dead editions, or vintage 1970s Chuck Taylors loom large on the resale market, with value soaring to $300-$1,000 or more, depending on condition and rarity.

Original packaging, blue and red laces, and certificates of authenticity can only drive the price up. Any pairs gathering dust in your closet could be a ticket to easy money!

Disclaimer: The Finance Key does not provide and does not intend to provide financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Information contained in this article is for informational and educational purposes only. This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information. The inclusion of links to third-party content is not an endorsement by The Finance Key of such content or services. Please do your due diligence and use your discretion.

Read More:

Photo Credit: Ivan Dudka/Shutterstock

Follow us on PinterestFollow

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Learn How to Build Wealth and Attain Financial Freedom! 

For the latest financial wisdom, straight to your inbox.

No thanks, I don't want to build wealth
Scroll to Top